Upon the former defender assumed control as Real Madrid's manager in the winter, he faced a severe lack of time to find his feet. A packed run of games translated to a phased integration to his squad was simply not feasible.
Pundits in Spain warned of the difficulties he would confront, particularly handling a dressing room packed with some of football's most prominent stars.
But building solid bonds with the footballers appeared not to worry the ex- Anfield defender.
"It's not an aspect that concerns me a lot," Arbeloa said at his inaugural media appearance.
Eight weeks later, he says those relationships are strengthening and the outcomes on the field are reflecting that.
Building Bonds
In March, the Madrid boss led his team to wins against sides coached by world-class coaches: the Portuguese manager's the Lisbon side, Pep Guardiola's City and Diego Simeone's Atletico Madrid.
Real Madrid remain a quartet of points behind the Spanish league pace-setters their arch-rivals, with a potentially decisive El Clasico in the spring, while their Champions League journey rolls on with a last-eight clash against Bayern Munich.
Real's results are getting better and the chemistry between the coach and squad are building.
"I am becoming to know the individuals better and better," commented the head coach following his team's 3-2 win against rivals Atletico recently.
"I arrived at a moment when I practically had insufficient time to observe the squad, to see where they were at ease, and to see how they mixed with one another."
He admitted the circumstances of his arrival created fresh difficulties.
"In my case, it's difficult to arrive mid-season and analyze how the team functions, and that is precisely what has evolved over these two months," he went on.
"At present I understand my charges as individuals and footballers, where I can extract the optimal performance from them, and where I can tweak things."
Plaudits for Vinicius Jr
One player flourishing under Arbeloa is the Brazilian winger.
He has started 16 of his new coach's 17 fixtures in charge, with his goal return also seeing a dramatic uptick - he has netted 11 times under the current boss, compared to scoring just six in 27 appearances under his predecessor.
The coach has prioritized rebuilding the attacker's morale, pushing him to play freely and be creative rather than constraining him tactically.
"I am fortunate to have Vini, he's cherished by the entire fanbase. We want to see the Vini who has fun on the pitch, who smiles, who celebrates… that is the Vini I want to see," Arbeloa stated in his initial news conference as manager.
This philosophy differs from rumors of tension under the previous manager, with Vinicius muttering "I'm going to leave this club" after being taken off in October's match against Barcelona.
The new boss has openly defended him, making clear he is has the total confidence by the coaching staff and the dressing room.
"He is among the most dangerous players, if not the most dangerous, in the world today and he embodies what a Real Madrid star is," said the manager.
Vinicius put talks about his long-term prospects on hold last off-season but, last week, he made his commitment clear.
"I'm only thinking about Real Madrid and remaining here for a long time," he told the media before his national team's friendly match with the French team.
Fede Valverde Recaptures Form Again
The Uruguayan midfielder's performances has also skyrocketed since Arbeloa arrived.
During the tenure of the previous coach, he contributed three strikes and seven assists from 31 games.
Since Arbeloa's appointment, he has been named in the starting eleven for all 17 of his matches in charge, finding the net seven times and registering five assists.
A key factor has been a positional shift back into midfield.
Throughout Alonso's tenure, the player at times found it hard to secure a regular place in his natural role, being deployed in unfamiliar positions such as full-back.
While the move was partly due to injuries to teammates, his frustration was clear. "I was not made to be a right-back," he said.
Yet now, restored to his preferred position, Valverde is thriving.
He has scored six goals in just a month, including a three-goal haul against City and a winning goal in a 3–2 triumph over Atletico Madrid.
Fresh Faces, Greater Possibilities?
The manager's prior role as boss of the club's B team has made blending youth prospects into the first team feel seamless, so it was expected to expect him to give emerging talent chances.
This was seen more notably when the team played their opponents earlier this month and the coach handed playing time to six youth team graduates.
A particular individual, in particular, has quickly broken through as one of Arbeloa's most promising youngsters.
At just 18 years and 226 days old, he became the most youthful footballer in the team's records to start twice in the Champions League knockout stages, surpassing a previous mark by 10 days.
Questioned what it signified to see several homegrown players on the pitch, he couldn't contain his pride.
"I think I can be content after a night like this one," he remarked.
"I was recently speaking with two of them, who were the initial youngsters I managed when they were very young, and to be able to give them the opportunity to perform at the Santiago Bernabeu is a dream come true for me."
While Arbeloa might be well-acquainted with the Castilla players, he concedes injuries have curtailed his exposure